At 83, carefully coiffed, impeccably turned out, sunny, and very much in love, Edie Windsor is going to be our representative before the Supreme Court on March 27 when it hears her case challenging the constitutionality of the Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA).
Unfortunately, Edie will go without her beloved Thea Spyer, her partner since the early 60s, who died in 2009. It was her death that brought Edie face-to-face with DOMA. Although Edie and Thea married in Canada in 2007, the U.S. federal government said they were legal strangers, and charged Edie 50% tax on everything Thea had given her over 40 years. The bill came to over $350,000, and Edie sued. It is her case the Supreme Court chose when asked to choose among multiple cases challenging the constitutionality of DOMA.
“The idea that I might be a piece of history blows my mind. I think it’s kind of wonderful that I’m getting my chance to really ask for justice, and I suspect I’ll get it. I’m still that little kid from the civics class. And I think they’re going to rule in our favor because I think that’s just.”
For a long article on Edie and Thea, including how their story illustrates and intersects with LGBT history in this country, go to http://www.buzzfeed.com/chrisgeidner/meet-the-hero-of-the-marriage-equality-movement
Edith Windsor, 83, widow of Thea Spyer, this week defeated the federal Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA).
When her partner of 42 years died in 2009, two years after the two had married in Canada, the federal government, citing DOMA, billed her $363,053. New York State followed suit, requiring taxes of $200,000. Much of the “inheritance” Ms. Windsor was paying taxes on were the house she and Thea had bought for $35,000 and the apartment they’d bought for $300,000: both had grown considerably in their worth in the decades they’d owned them. Had she and Thea been a heterosexual married couple, she would have been allowed to take full posession of their homes without paying a dime in taxes.
This week, in one of several cases nationwide challenging the constitutionality of DOMA, Ms. Windsor won her case. It is expected that the Supreme Court will be asked to review one or all of those lower court decisions that DOMA is unconstitutional. To read more about Ms. Windsor, you can see a New York Times article at http://www.nytimes.com/2012/06/08/nyregion/woman-says-same-sex-marriage-bias-cost-her-over-500000.html?_r=3&smid=fb-share
|The following is the 2011 “Gennys,” awarded by the people behind Gen Silent: Continue reading
What does an 81-year-old lesbian widow have to do with President Obama? Her lawsuit to try to recover $353,053 that the federal government took from her in estate taxes when her spouse died was cited as one of the reasons the Obama Administration announced on February 23 that it will not continue defending the Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA) from charges of unconstitutionality.
Edith Windsor and Thea Spyer first met in 1963. Their love story is breathtakingly portrayed in the video “Edie and Thea: A Very Long Engagement,” (available at http://www.breakingglasspictures.com/index.php?option=com_jmovies&Itemid=2&task=detail&id=73). The film follows them for several years near the end of Thea’s life, and includes footage of their Canadian wedding in 2007, when they were 77 and 75.